Evaroni's Pizza

Great pie.

Great sauce!

Best. Pizza. Ever. The sauce is to die for.

Probably the best pizza in the area.

You just can’t beat it. Best pizza in WV. Best sauce ever

Cheese with extra sauce here. This pie is one of the better to taste in the area. The sauce has great flavor and the crust isn’t too hard. The cheese stays on the pizza with every bite. Great Pizza.

By far, the best pizza I’ve ever had in a restaurant. The sauce is to die for. I love thin crust pizza and this is definitely the best. I really wish I didn’t love 2 hours away! The service was excellent. Very nice people.

One bite everyone knows the rules🍕 The sauce alone is perfection, matter of fact, maybe the BEST I’ve eaten. The pizza, has crossed the 9.0 plateau. Yes, I gave in a 9.0, but well deserved.

An old local favorite!!! Sauce is a little sweet for me personally but crust and cheese is very good.

It’s fine pizza but the sauce is too sweet. Edge crust reminded me of a DiGorno. Middle slice was much better.

Not a fan of sweet sauce so that hurts my score for this landmark pizzaria. Nice crust and fresh ingredients are a plus. Evaroni’s is my wife’s favorite in the 3-state region.

Great sweet sauce. Crust could be thinner, but its tasty.

One of the best pizzas WV has to offer. It has a unique sweet sauce and the crust is always perfect. Could use a more generous serving of pepperoni.

Paisley gives out a perfect 10. Rookie score but we’ll take it.

sweet sauce. Potato chip crust. Not too bad