Famous Ben's Pizza

Solid New York slice here with very fresh ingredients, especially the cheese. The sauce was also really good and had a hint of sweetness. The crust was nice and crispy… at the ends, but there was a decent amount of NY flop. (Cheese slice only)

They’re known for their Sicilian slice so I broke the normal rules. It tastes like traditional bakery pizza. Very thick, but surprisingly light and not greasy. Italian ice was a 9.5 on a 100° day

Had not been here in over 20 years. I recalled it being much better back in the day. Nice light, no flop crust makes it slightly better than average for NYC.

Who am I to disagree with El Pres?

They kind of skimped me on the Sicilian slice

Great crunch, no flop. Preferred over Joe’s (8.3), so went with 8.5. Would get again next time I’m in Soho!

Very good Sicilian slice.

Cheese was good, a little too much sauce. Crust was way too doughy

Love the crust and the cheese

Awesome crunch! Kick ass sauce. Would have gotten in the 8s if we got a whole pie to order.30 min travel pizza

Not impressed

Very average. Saucy pizza

MEGA ALAKAZAM

Avg slice, nothing special

Cheese round slice. Had been sitting out for a while, but it still burned my face off after being reheated in the oven

The regular cheese slice is the best. The Sicilian is also excellent. The gimmicky pizzas are hit and miss but if you stick with authentic cheese slice cheese Sicilian and regular white you can’t go wrong. This is an awesome find! Eat here!!

good crunch, needs more cheese