21,334 views•1,664 likes
jim528997/8/20, 1:02 a.m.
I have to say this pie was a little disappointing, especially after seeing all of the great reviews! I can only hope that they were having an off day or something. Sauce was good, crust was a little burnt and pie was very greasy. I ate it but it made me sad.
bscottd6/13/20, 2:13 a.m.
Great crust... crunchy like a cracker. Love the little edge burn.
18 views•2 likes
davin.moskal5/13/20, 12:37 a.m.
Growing up in Ocean / Monmouth county, this has always been my favorite pizza place. I’ve been saying for years that Dave should check it out. Everything I love on a pizza; thin, crispy, well done, and not too greasy. I’ll make the argument that Federici’s is the best pizza in Monmouth county.
jason.derosa15/2/20, 5:53 p.m.
Great pie for any occasion. One of the best NJ thin crust bar style pizza with minimal flop and a crunchy crust. Be careful if you fold the pizza as grease will drip off the back end and catch you. Cash only, but ATM located at the door of the back entrance.
joeybasile4/30/20, 5:17 p.m.
Great Pizza, thin crust, crispy, really good sauce. It was a little greasy but the overall flavor made up for it
djl3wis4/24/20, 7:16 p.m.
Dave the blogger ratted this place 8.8. It is pretty good got to admit. I say it’s right around that ratting.
bobbybrezz4/14/20, 11:29 p.m.
I always get Sausage & Pepper well done in a bag! It’s against the rules but it’s soooo good! For some reason it taste better in a bag instead of a box.
bababooey693/19/20, 9:06 p.m.
Very very good bar pie. Great crunch. Scarfed this down in about 20 mins. I’m disgusted with myself. Still think Star Tavern is the best though.
ken.deangelo3/19/20, 7:08 p.m.
Solid bar pie good sauce nice crunch. A little greasy to go much higher for me.
shajony3/18/20, 8:41 p.m.
I don’t get how he rated that an 8.8 Nothing but grease and no flavor. Chunky cheese was better than that.. sorry to say.
kevin.price3/17/20, 9:05 p.m.
Chanced gettin the beervirus for this and was so worth it. If I have to spend two weeks sick or dead I’ll have this as my lasting memory. The cheese sauce ratio is perfect and the crust is paper thin but cooked perfect. I could eat ten of these bitches and still have room for some deep dish trash from the Chicago.