Fire Engine Pizza Co

Doughy crust

I love this style pizza it’s right in my wheelhouse. Great crisp crust and good char throughout- would have been an 8 but they dumped Parmesan cheese on it and I don’t like that.

My Highest Score in Connecticut !! Margherita was Fire !! (Picture not shown)

Staff gets an f- minus. Pizza is phenomenal

Incredible flavor

Had to take a picture from their Facebook. The Sunday dinner was gone before I could take a picture of it!! lol🤣

Best pie in Black rock area, excellent bar pizza, cheese and sauce are excellent, good dough, undercarriage cooked perfect, no flop, crunchy crust...best known for mash potato pie

A small is great for a personal sitting. Great sauce, good crunch. No flop but a little greasy

Very good pizza. I like the touch of parmesan on top!

Little flop good crunch... needs a little tang in the sauce

First impression is that there is not a balanced cheese to sauce ratio on this pie. However, after a second bite, it becomes apparent that the cheese is actually the star of this pizza. The crust is tasty, but not as crisp as I like. It is also slightly doughy leading to a lower score but overall, this is good pizza, not great.

Loaded mashed potato pizza

Solid - can be cooked a bit more to make it crispier. Sauce is tasty. Solid NY style pizza.