Old reliable. This is the type of pizza you travel out of your way for. Over the hills and far away. Great song by none other than Led Zepplin. Remember when 95.1 used to play songs at 8 o’clock each night? A whole lotta Led?? Those were the days....But anyway, pizza was phenomenal. It very well maybe the perfect pie, but can anyone top this? There has to be some one out there than can, But idk that remains to be seen...
bigbear778/14/20, 8:55 p.m.
Great stop today. Was in town and had to go to the best. Service was outstanding, especially given COVID and accommodating so many for. Friday lunch rush. #Highlyrecomended good crust, right amount of cheese, great dough flavor with oven char.
noah.weiss38/13/20, 8:42 p.m.
I’ve had Pepe’s a few times throughout my life, and this is the first time in a year and I have to say this isn’t one of my best experiences due to Covid, however this pie kicks any other places ass so I have to go 7.9
adam.rothgarn8/10/20, 7:15 p.m.
Great char, slight flop, great basil taste in the sauce, a bit heavier on the cheese than Sally’s. Another great pie on Wooster.
rob.whipple8/4/20, 6:19 p.m.
Amazing pizza. Nice char on the crust and crispy bottom. Can’t go wrong
vtboost8/1/20, 4:51 p.m.
Love the crust, sauce, not too much cheese. Has flop but I love thin crust pizza. Would definitely drive 2 hours again for this!
haley.ferreira7/25/20, 11:56 a.m.
Awesome pizza. Much more flavorful than Sally’s. Solid pizza
laurr7/21/20, 6:43 p.m.
Ok Pepe’s, as much as I would have liked to have made you my New Haven favorite because of your impressive history... The crust was still just as good with the famous at the beach, “put my mouth on a charcoal grill” flavor. The cheese was light and fluffy. Nothing can override you. You stand on your own, you independent sexy saucy thing. See ya soon.
charles.tetro7/12/20, 4:26 p.m.
Very good New Haven style apizza. Had this clam pie and a delicious mozzarella pie.