luke.sherlockgh11/26/21, 6:53 p.m.
Good but crust was a bit off lost some grease and garlicky flavor
kenny.terrell11/17/21, 6:40 p.m.
Pizza was greasy which is great, however the crisp wasn’t a crunchy crisp. It was thin and almost needed to be torn apart.
brandon.perman11/16/21, 4:18 a.m.
Wasn’t wowed by the cheese and sauce. The crunch propelled the score!
9 views•1 like
km01111/9/21, 2:04 a.m.
I had to decide for myself if Frank Pepe's deserves it's #1 in the U.S ranking (5 years in a row now). If it's not the best, it's definitely one of them! The crust and flavor of the cheese will blow your mind ! Awesome char on the outer portion of the crust, with an electric crunch in every bite ! Be ready to wait a while for a table and even longer for a takeout order, as this place is busy 24/7! If you're a seafood lover, go with the white clam pie, as it's the sole reason this place is as famous and well known as it is!
stevepizzareviews11/6/21, 6:34 p.m.
Great pizza, but a bit too oily to bring this in the 9s. Also needs more sauce .
pmw10/24/21, 11:50 p.m.
8.6 for the regular. Great crust. Good sauce. Creamy cheese. Could maybe use a little parm/ salt to take it over the top. Really good. HOWEVER 9.5 pepperoni slice. Best pepperoni pizza I’ve had in my whole life. Best pepperoni I’ve ever had probably is the reason. Thick, real pepperoni makes this pizza out of this world. So far my highest score. Best pizza slice I’ve ever had (robertas bee sting probably in that low / mid 9s camp also. But wow.
lailalikespizza10/20/21, 6:11 p.m.
Very strong flavor and crust. Really not a fan of how they cut the pie tho...didn’t let it affect score but who does that?
ellmo10/19/21, 4:53 p.m.
Great pizza. Cheese was special nothing like I’ve tasted and sauce was tangy but not like overly tangy. Crisp and thin just like I like it. Smoky and just overall delicious
bearking7210/18/21, 3:24 a.m.
Not much to offer here. Little sauce. Good char crust so so cheese was good quality. Over all for a bucket list pizza destination ,no big celebration.
thedaydreamer10/17/21, 8:52 p.m.
I had the white clam pizza. Great pizza! The amount of cheese was perfect. The end tasted like a burnt cracker.
mark.genco10/15/21, 10:26 p.m.
Great crust, nice char and a good crisp. Sauce is zesty, but pizza was a bit greasy, especially the half that was just cheese. Oddly the side with pepperoni and cherry peppers was less greasy. Definitely worth the stop. Will try Sally’s or Modern next time I am in town.
patrick.oneill110/14/21, 1:56 a.m.
Only 8.5 was the cream soda. Not the best crust or cheese. Actually Poor quality cheese, flavorless sauce.
john.wlasuk10/10/21, 1:33 a.m.
Crunchy crust, sauce and cheese combo strong. First time at New Haven location - a step above their other locations.