First time trying pizza in Beaver County! I have heard about the friendly rivalry between Frank’s and Police Station for years. Police Station actually won 2022 Pittsburgh Pizza of the Year! I was extremely excited to try this place. It has been around since 1957 and they load the pie with sauce, so my expectations were extremely high. Unfortunately not all of my expectations were met. I just didn’t love the sauce, I feel like I’ve tasted that exact pizza sauce on mall pizza. I wasn’t a fan of its consistency either. I usually like my sauce thinner than this, but you wouldn’t be able to put it on top of the cheese like that. I couldn’t really get a good taste of the cheese because it’s under the sauce, but there’s a lot of it. The dough and crust are perfect, but that should be the minimum prerequisite if the place has been around for four generations. I wish I liked this pizza as much as everyone else does up here. The sauce is just too boring to have so much of it on the pie. Next time I’m up in Ambridge I’ll have to try the “Best Pizza in Pittsburgh.”
