Freddie & Pepper's

crust: 7/10 sauce: 5/10 cheese: 3/10

The cheese pull on this pizza was crazy! Lot of the cheese ending up falling off, but this was still so crispy and delicious!

Pretty good undercarriage, good sauce and decent cheese. Overall a good slice.

Quite thick and very cheesy. I’d say that both slices were alright, but the cheese was so heavy on the slice that it started to actually fall onto the plate as I was eating it. VERY heavy flop on both slices because of this. The taste was fine enough, though— nothing outstanding but not bad either. Location near the Beacon Theater is great. If you’re a fan of thick slices with lots of cheese I’d say go for this one, but it’s not my personal preference

This is the meat lovers pizza. Average to good, well baked but not enough sauce. It ripped in the middle too so tough to eat. Definitely not the 8.1 Dave gave it before.

This slice immediately separates itself due to fresh taste and elite-level crunch. The crust has that perfect snap on the first bite — crispy without being dry. Every component tastes clean and intentional, from the bright sauce to the quality cheese. Yes, it leans a bit on the greasy side — but it aids flavor. Enjoy!

Good pizza

Slightly above avg. Had the CBR and house special. Lots of flop, very gooey cheesy.

just made the account and didn’t take pictures. owner’s son was very nice but that doesn’t make the pizza. was very good though. classic spot. solid. minimal flop, good flavor.

Greasy, but solid. Good pep good cheese. Good pizza. Could be a tiny bit tastier

8.2, that’s a review

Best pizza I have ever had. No flop but still a fluffy crust. Flavor is unreal. Tastes like the flavor that Little Caesars was tryin to achieve with an incredible texture.

Great spot for a slice

Can’t believe Dave gave a 8.1 This place has been around too long to be serving bad stuff like this. Service was strange in there too can’t imagine what it’s like with a busy line. Pizza was a mess no structure but the sauce was a decent taste. The crust dough was practically raw couldn’t eat crust.