Freddy’s Pizza Whitestone

Thin crispy crust. Sauce is very flavorful

This place has history and has been around since 1961, even longer than me. The last time I was here was in 1995. Yes, I said I was old. The place has been renovated nicely inside with the classic, old school Freddy's Pizza sign still out front. The place has plenty of seats, nicely air conditioned in 90-degree NYC weather, cool dance music playing, and the service was excellent. I ordered 2 Sicilian slices with the sesame seeded bottom crust. Tasty. I enjoyed them. I will be back, promise.

Old school Pizzeria Vibe, Sicilian was very good, thought it was going to be heavy but light and crispy. Sesame seeds on the bottom was a nice touch. Also enjoyed the vodka slice.

Scary good slice!!!! Got the old Sicilian signature slice at Freddy’s pizza and wow is it unique!!! The sesame seed undercarriage gives it a different dynamic in texture I’ve only tried once before. Great crisp as well from the crust yet extremely pillowy and flexible in the middle like you’d want. The sauce is very rich fresh and sweet, a great compliment to the flavors from underneath and topped with a more fresh mozz cheese with a little bit of basil cooked in. Around I think since 71 it’s an awesome counter slice shop that’s another one of those old school spots you gotta hit!!!

Good solid neighborhood slice. Not too much nor cheese , a good combo of both

Right near my families home in Whitestone, where I grew up. David Portnoy was here once and said the dough was a bit thick. I did not see that, but I saw a really well put together very enjoyable slice of pizza. When I rate an 8.1 or higher it means it is worth a pretty long drive to get there!!

Regular not bad. A little to greasy and heavy on the cheese 7.4 The vodka grandma was very bland 7.2 I really came here for the Sicilian. The put sesame seeds all over the bottom. Was dissapointed they didnt help the slice much at all 7.1

Regular: thin and crispy sauce and cheese are a good ratio and taste great. easy 8.1 Sicilan: dough is cooked perfect for a sicilan, again sauce and cheese are a ratio and taste great 8.5

Tha was an absolute sauce party, and not in a good way.

Zero flop. Good crunch. Sweet sauce. Good overall taste. Football pizza!

Very disappointing slice. Extremely greasy and way too much cheese.

Crunchy but fluffy, some grease but deal with it! Plain slice belongs in the 8’s! Bonus review, Fried Calzone = 9.5.

Best Sicilian (a.k.a square) slice ever! Sesame seeds under the crust are a nice finishing touch. Dave missed this one for sure.

Good slice, sauce a little too sweet, thick crust

Probably the best Sicilian I have found so good not doughy great cheese and sauce and a sesame seed bottom adds to it

A decent Sicilian slice. Definitely have had better. Needs more sauce. Sesame seed crust was different. Wouldn’t go out of my way for it.

Mild flop. Great cheese. Crust was a little too doughy. Good pizza

A rather average NYC slice. Lacks the wow factor comparative to other standard slice shops. Cheese is okay, sauce just isn’t there.