Garden City Pizza and Catering

Go Sicilian all the way here in Garden City!!! It’s thick, the sauce was good and the seasoning hits the spot! The regular slice was just ok for me. It had no flop, but was definitely over cooked so it was on the harder side. The oil was a little excessive for me. I would look elsewhere for regular slices.

Classic Long Island pizza. Good crust good sauce.

Baked ziti slice

Heard mixed things, pleasantly surprised with a very respectable slice at a party. A classic “football pizza”

Has all the appearances of a well constructed slice... no flop, good look and texture. Unfortunately it’s exactly as I’ve remembered from years of living in garden city, a bit too much cardboard taste from the crust and the strong cheese taste overwhelms the sauce.

Solid slice with a good crunch and an abundance of tasty cheese. Only demoted bc sauce could use more flavor.