Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood

This pizza isn’t New Haven style but it was delicious. I would order from them again.

Cheese slice reviewed and buffalo chicken slice extra.

Nice and crispy, Just the right amount of sauce.

Good sauce to cheese ratio. Slightly greasy with little flop. Unburnt with crunchy crust

Good nys pizza, amazing cheese but took away from the sauce, not too bad, I like the crust, crispy and good flavor,but could of been in the 8's if the sauce have a zing and more flavor

Great flavor, always cooked right

Eh... very chewy. Sauce not bad.

Blink and you’ll miss this place. There is no parking so expect to walk if it’s a busy time of day... This is a real thin slice type of place which is a bonus. Absolutely no crisp on the bottom, only in the crust. The cheese has no real depth leaving the sauce (which is sweet) for all the flavor. The sauce itself needs more seasoning and it doesn’t blend well with this slice. The ingredients are here for good pizza but this place falls short of execution. So far, these late night pizza reviews haven’t been good...

Good Cheese Pizza, little flop, and not too much grease. Pretty good

Buffalo chicken was fair at best, ive had worse. The cheese and pepperoni was brutal. The sauce needs a lot of work. Seem like nice guys inside but food is sub par.

No flop, bottom underdone, and crust burnt

A very good amount of flop. Sauce is ok and the cheese is good. Nice firm crust

Some flop, good cheese. Sauce is nothing to brag about. Good crisp on the crust.

Great slice. Little grease, little flop, great sauce. Dough a little chewy but great crunch on the crust.