Gino's of Manhasset

Best slice on the Island. Amazing cheese. Perfect crisp. Beautiful undercarriage. Beautiful interior and amazing staff. Best Spot.

Consistently the best slice on Long Island

Very solid, crispy and flavorful “average” slice. I accidentally ordered the grandma with no cheese, but it was actually pretty great!

One Bite. Everybody Knows the Rules. Wow what a slice of Pizza. Came out Hot and Fresh. Great crust. Amazing crust. Cheese to sauce ratio was really good. Very tasty slice. There is a good amount of parking in the back as parking might be tough on the main road. Highly recommend this place.

Talk about split at the edges, feast your eyes on this slice. As soon as the pizza guy handed me the slice I knew this was going to be one of those slices that crumbles as soon as you pick it up. Guess what? It crumbled. Super oily, cheese just slide right off and piled up on my plate. Crust was super thin, not the crunch your looking for. I ended up eating the pile of cheese at the end. Sauce was pretty good and the cheese was not too bad. I would head to Umbertos for pizza in this area. Enjoy!!!

Pretty oily. Very hot. Not the best but not the worst

Went in not expecting much, but i must say, i was surprised The sicilian slice was one of the better sicilian slices ive ever had. Very fresh tasting, dough and crust perfectly cooked. The sauce was a thicker sauce with a lot of flavor. If i was rating just this, 9.1 Regular slice was prettt blah. 0 flop which is great, but very greasy, cheese had no bite to it, and not enough sauce nor could i taste sauce over the cheese and grease. 4.8 Rigatoni ala vodka - thin slice with a good amount of pasta and sauce. Pasta was cooked perfectly, sauce was solid, perfect amount of cheese. 0 complaints . 7.8

The Margherita slice tasted a little bland for me compared to others I’ve tried.. the Neapolitan slice on the other hand tasted better.. to each his own I guess.. WFAN’s Mike Francesa loves this place! Peace y’all ✌️

Best slice on Plandome Road

Rigatoni a la vodka slice

Lots of grease on this bad boy, but good crisp. Marinara and cheese are standard. A decent slice. That’s a review Frank!!

Good

A good slice, kinda sweet sauce and gooey cheese. A thin slice with a crispy crust, no flop. A little greasy. Overall a good local slice.

Tasty with good crunch and cheese, a little too greasy!

Slice number 2. Crust is a little thick and the pizza is a little greasy. Would eat here all the time.

Perfect sauce/cheese ratio. Nice crunch.

Pretty typical slice. I like their sauce, it’s a basic marinara and the cheese isn’t too greasy. Large selection of pizza and other Italian dishes. Most importantly, my girlfriend loves this place.

Sauce has a sweet taste to it. Cheese is thick not too oily. Over all a bland slice of pizza.

Best on Plandome Road

Dave, you have to try this place. Best pizza, hands down