Glenville Pizza

Good taste, prefer the Frankie thin pizza more

Was too busy chatting up my date to eat it while it was hot. Tastes fire crust was fine. Cheese tastes great, reminds me of my ex wife’s home cooking. She cheated me with our family friend and took the kids. I owe her so much in alimony and she won’t even let me talk to them. I really like the pizza but hate my ex. Thanks Glenville, I’ll now be loyal to you, unlike my ex wife to me. Cheers.

Very solid pizza. Overall solid plain, almost no flop, well done, but sauce lacks sweetness. I review plain slices, but the rest of the pizza is awesome. I would recommend Sicilian or vodka slice.

Nice crisp good flavor nice owners

Zero flop! Great crunch! Amazing taste. Lite and crunchy and thin! Good undercarriage. Tried the new hot honey pepperoni as well. Its awesome!!

Southern Connecticut pizza is very different from the Northern New Haven style. Established in 1976, this pizza is a staple of Greenwich and being so close the the New York border, it’s definitely more NY football style. To be completely honest, this pizza made me think I had Covid from lack of smell & taste. It’s rare you walk into a pizzeria and it doesn’t smell incredible with fresh pies wafting through the air. It’s also really hard to make a practically flavorless pizza. This is really shocking cause the pie looks good, has great texture, just no taste whatsoever. I’ve had sauce with no flavor before, and dough that was boringly bland but I can’t ever remember the cheese not having some kind of taste. That’s not to say this pizza has an unpleasant taste; it’s not disgusting or foul. It’s just way too greasy, oil gushing on every bite and less flavorful than an ice cube. This is the perfect example of even when pizza isn’t great, it’s still just decent enough to eat. Some say the Sicilian pie is the featured item here; but I can assure you, their regular plain pizza certainly isn’t.

This is a Sicilian joint. As far as I know, there is some history between Sals in Mamaroneck and the owner of Glenville. Some of the best square pizza/Sicilian I’ve had. Regular and others are pretty good too. Sit down is a must. Good crunch, ton of cheese, flavorful sauce, and some decent oven work on this bad boy. Very good pizza, this is a repeat spot and not sure how Dave messed this up. You just don’t order a regular slice at a Sicilian spot.

Better than average for sure based on flavor and crisp, but otherwise a very standard slice shop here.

Standard good slice. Definitely on greasy side and floppy

Great classic slice

Greasy over done . Crust no taste . Left gross grease smell on my fingers on drive home can’t wait to wash my hands.

I have an extra 2 points bc I got reheated slice. Great ZA

One bite everybody knows the rules, grabbed a quick cheese slice at lunch, 0 NY flop, very crispy which I like but lacks flavor big time. The sauce is literally tasteless. One bite everybody knows the rules. 6.4 not the worst I ever had but not great at all.

Solid crisp

Very solid slice. Very crispy crust and great cheese + sauce. S/o Vinny the pizza twirler.