Top Restaurants

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN

Pizza Review

0 likes

kevthesliceman on One Bite Pizza App

kevthesliceman

12/9/22 10:51 PM

Was pretty excited about this one, considering Dave gave it a 8.1. But honestly, it left a lot to be desired. Ingredients were all quality, but they seemed in the wrong proportions. The amount of sauce left this tasting almost like a white pizza, where the cheese overpowered everything else. Good undercarriage with minimal flop, but could have used an extra minute or two in the oven to crispen it up. The dough was a bit soft and tasted slightly undercooked. Not sure if this was just an off day for them, but overall not very impressed.

Pizza Review

sam.hounsell4/7/24, 11:22 p.m.

7.6

Pizza Review

solefocus3/30/24, 3:06 a.m.

6.3

Very doughy…no crisp…sauce is sub par. I did door dash this but I was not far away…def not an 8.1

Pizza Review

dylan.grubbs3/26/24, 1:02 a.m.

1.0

This was awful. Dave must’ve been on drugs.

Pizza Review

aweandsome3/18/24, 10:13 p.m.

7.9

Good NY slice. Not too greasy. Sauce is light. Make sure they cook it long enough to get the full effect.

Pizza Review

cory.stickley3/13/24, 7:05 p.m.

6.9

Fresh out of oven. Greaseball from the pepperoni but good cheese and flavor on toppings. Standard tomato sauce. Solid overall with little flop. Downfall of super doughy crust

Pizza Review

joseph.kroehler3/6/24, 6:21 p.m.

8.1

My favorite Indy pizza spot!!! Love the speak easy in the back, amazing bourbons, fantastic atmosphere! Great price, awesome slice!

Pizza Review

tmsmedic2/7/24, 8:03 p.m.

8.2

Just damn good pizza. Light but substantial. Good sauce cheese and ingredients. Perfectly cooked and undercarriage is on point. Bar side is where you need to get this pie.

Pizza Review

ben.battles12/10/23, 4:18 a.m.

7.9

So close to an eight! Wanted to try pep & cheese - they have a half and half. 22” pie, this thing barely fit into my car through the front door. Sauce is top tier, wish it had a bit more crisp in the crust - but overall… did not disappoint!

Pizza Review

walkerlasbury12/9/23, 4:49 p.m.

9.0

Best pizza I’ve ever had. Perfect crispy crust and flavor.

Pizza Review

bobstarnes12/1/23, 6:38 p.m.

0.0

Pizza Review

rustyd11/25/23, 2:46 a.m.

5.8

Not sure what Pizza Dave had but the Pizza I had was doughy cheese with very little sauce. I asked for it well done and it was still floppy. The place is open till 3:00 am for a reason. It’s drunk Pizza. The inside of the restaurant is a filthy dirty. I would not recommend!!!

Pizza Review

mpd15011/13/23, 8:37 p.m.

8.0

Very large slices! Very good garlic bread!!

Pizza Review

lennoll110/27/23, 8:33 p.m.

7.2

After mentally stripping the sausage and pep, and based on the gold bar NJ/NY scale, this slice lands squarely in Average Town. Decent undercarriage, but super doughy handle. Good sauce. Portnoy was a rookie himself when he rated this one.

Pizza Review

vincent.solano9/8/23, 7:45 p.m.

7.8

Pizza was good and service was friendly. The bar in the back made had an amazing selection of whiskeys which made the experience even better.

Pizza Review

pdrew12119/2/23, 9:42 p.m.

8.3

Pizza Review

cristhian.rodriguez8/27/23, 1:38 a.m.

8.5

Great crisp and great undercarriage! No flop at all. Crust was delicious! Cheese to sauce ratio was very well balanced.

Pizza Review

isaac.ott8/8/23, 10:23 p.m.

7.9

Definitely had a good flavor crust was crispy but just a touch burnt but overall really good

Pizza Review

steve.mace7/9/23, 5:46 p.m.

7.6

No flop and tasty. It has its own unique crust.

Pizza Review

jeff.shadbolt7/2/23, 2:32 a.m.

8.2

Pizza Review

lewis.fuller6/10/23, 9:08 p.m.

7.9

Crust needed to be cooked a little longer. Floppy and a little doughy.

Pizza Review

timmy.risden6/3/23, 8:51 p.m.

8.5

First time on the app, already found a gem. Inside is a super cool speakeasy with a nice selection. New to Indy but this has to be the best pizza spot here.

Pizza Review

jillianlouise5/25/23, 11:28 p.m.

4.8

I’m gonna assume I caught them on a bad day. The picture says it all

Pizza Review

jaxon.sivils5/21/23, 4:58 p.m.

8.5

Very impressed, outstanding!

Pizza Review

jtc4/28/23, 8:24 p.m.

6.1

Breadstick was better than the slice….heavy on the cheese solid dough & crust….thinner would be better….

Pizza Review

jason.bryant34/24/23, 11:05 p.m.

7.7

Good pizza perfect crust hardly no flop at all!!