Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

Great crisp and great undercarriage! No flop at all. Crust was delicious! Cheese to sauce ratio was very well balanced.

Definitely had a good flavor crust was crispy but just a touch burnt but overall really good

No flop and tasty. It has its own unique crust.

Crust needed to be cooked a little longer. Floppy and a little doughy.

First time on the app, already found a gem. Inside is a super cool speakeasy with a nice selection. New to Indy but this has to be the best pizza spot here.

I’m gonna assume I caught them on a bad day. The picture says it all

Very impressed, outstanding!

Breadstick was better than the slice….heavy on the cheese solid dough & crust….thinner would be better….

Good pizza perfect crust hardly no flop at all!!

Boy. This place is energizing. The staff is friendly and inviting. Zero flop and quality dough. Multiple employees up front talked about the pride of their “dough guy” in the back. Worth the stop. We like a little more flavor/ salt in the cheese blend. Can see why this gets in the 8s.

Fixing rating.

Yeah, Indy!

Big Ole Slice of 🍕 Good solid undercarriage Nice greese to cheese ratio. Crispy crust. Very nice 🍕

As close to New York as you can get. Excellent pizza! Simple…fresh…and delicious! Must try in Indy!

Great pizza, the dough is perfect.

Solid late night pie

Perfect slice of pizza besides a little Little mushy

Was pretty excited about this one, considering Dave gave it a 8.1. But honestly, it left a lot to be desired. Ingredients were all quality, but they seemed in the wrong proportions. The amount of sauce left this tasting almost like a white pizza, where the cheese overpowered everything else. Good undercarriage with minimal flop, but could have used an extra minute or two in the oven to crispen it up. The dough was a bit soft and tasted slightly undercooked. Not sure if this was just an off day for them, but overall not very impressed.

Really good pizza. Great atmosphere!! Bourbon bar in the back. Great place!!!

One bite

Tasty pie. Tad doughy. Fresh cheese and sauce. “Football Pizza”