Grimaldi's Pizzeria Garden City

Good flavor, a lot of flop, too much sauce (bad cheese-sauce ratio), extremely great crust and bread (truly top tier dough for LI) Overrated to be honest. Much better pizzerias in the GC area to choose from. It’s a decent pie, just not for the price.

Sauce and crust are amazing, definitely could be one of the best places on Long Island

Best cold fire I have ever had I would really recommend this place

Should’ve had it fresh, had it delivered. Very light, nice flavor, good balance.

Ma

Well it ain’t Fulton Street, but it gets the job done. Grabbed a half regular/half pepperoni pie and had high hopes due to the chain restaurant name. The slice was good, not great, very doughy and just so so in terms of taste. If your looking for a nice sit down dinner spot, this will probably do the job for you. If your looking for great coal oven pizza on LI, head North to Salvatore’s!!! Enjoy!!

Been to the one under the Brooklyn Bridge, but first time here. Never knew they had so many locations! Great pizza here, one of my favorites. Sauce, cheese & crust all delicous! Nothing better then sitting at the bar with a pie and a beer… There’s a front & back entrance, bar is in the back! Enjoy!!

Excellent Cheese, and toppings! Could use just a little more crisp on the under carriage, but aways a great pie from the coal oven.

Decent char very little flop but dough a bit chewy or else higher score.

Coal fired is right up my alley. Sauce and cheese were good. Cooked well.

Good, but the one in Brooklyn is probably better.