Old Forge was good overall. The sauce was the star, the cheese was fine, and the crust was thick and a bit dry for my taste, but you definitely get that classic Old Forge flavor. 7.8
The bar pie is the real standout. Cracker-thin cheeze-it like crust, much better enjoyed fresh while sitting down rather than as takeout. The cheese had a slightly pungent flavor, possibly provolone, and the sauce was solid. 8.1
