bambam.to2/6/21, 8:42 p.m.
It was the coldest day of the winter in NYC,and the pie lost some heat on the 10 mins walk home. Otherwise, could have been a higher score.
jordanberman9/24/20, 11:26 p.m.
Very solid slice. Quite thin, purposely a little burnt and good flavor. Definitely carries a heavy New York vibe. While this place isn’t necessarily incredible, theres nothing negative about it.
alex.hartelust6/17/20, 10:43 p.m.
Joe’s Pizza on Fulton Street, the “Spider Man” pizza pie. Good pie!
6 views•0 likes
kevlarltd2/21/20, 1:24 a.m.
- No flop, minimum amount of grease. No napkins were wasted on the pizza. - Cheese to Sauce: pretty even in terms of coverage. Regular slice was stringy due to high turnover but the Sicilian was not. I think you are getting your money's worth. -Taste: a hint of tangy, hint of sweetness from the cheese and tomatoes. With the nice charcoal on the bottom with the regular crust, I will gladly take people here who want NYC - style pizza. As for the Sicilian, too much bread, not enough cheese and sauce. Cannot skimp out on the good stuff when you are charging $4 a slice. $7.00 total ( $3 for the regular, $4 for the Sicilian ) out the door. Rating: 7.8 ( recommend the regular ).
paul.hotaling22/17/20, 7:14 p.m.
Wow. Tangy flavorful sauce, crisp crust. Good flavor. Really good slice!
diarmaidbhk2/15/20, 4:54 a.m.
It’s just as tiny as the original location. Not as packed as i imagined it would be on a Friday Night. Nice sauce and cheese balance. It’s got a nice chewiness to the crust. It’s missing that crunch on the bottom for a top score.
richard.garbett2/14/20, 9:45 p.m.
Great basic slice...nice balance of sauce and cheese...perfect eating temp!
mbulmer101012/13/19, 10:15 p.m.
Not as good as regular joes. But still top line slice. Great sauce per usual
ray.rivera10/30/19, 8:36 p.m.
I had 4 slices of cheese pizza and 1 corner Sicilian slice. Sicilian 8.2 Cheese Slice 7.9 The next 3 cheese slices (after my 1st slice) were significantly different than the 1st slice (they were from a fresh pie), and those merited an 8.1, but I have to stick to the original score of the 1st slice (7.9) - Thin. - Could use more flavor on the sauce. - Greasier than expected for a thin slice. - Flop (you can see in the pic). - No crisp until the end - Good crust