Where's the flavor?
Order now on Slice
Order Joey's New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
floridascott2/9/22, 7:10 p.m.
Second stop today for National pizza day. Here by recommendation, Joey's NY Pizza. 1. Inside looks more like a higher end Restaurant than a pizza place. Took a short while to get my slice, not like some other places that are setup to just through a quick order in to the oven for people walking up to the counter. 2. Definitely NY style, but nothing really blew me away, just on the average side. 3. In the past I've said that a drop of salt could have helped places in the past, today is the first time I am actually saying there was too much salt. Crust could have used a bit more flavor. 4. My rating is 7.2
stavs10/21/21, 11:48 p.m.
This is the closest I’ve found to NY/NJ/Philly pizza in the Tampa area. I’ve been to Eddie and Sams which is what everyone recommends, and this blows it away. They use All Trump flour, Stanislaus tomatoes and Grande cheese. Pizza has little flop, not greasy and you can taste the freshness. $13 for a large pie is a bargain. The reheated slices come out nice and crisp. Fresh pies are great as well. Rating is based on comparison to other Tampa area spots. If this were in The Northeast it would be a 7.4.
xembre10/5/21, 10:31 p.m.
Update: pizza was cold took almost 2 hours to get delivered. Almost tasted stale Been ordering for over 5 years now but this last time will be it for me. Ordered one large cheese pizza and a salad for delivery was told 45 minutes and we ended up waiting over a hour and 30. I called to ask what happened and expect some service of better explanation and was just given the excuse that it gets busy I understand people are short staffed but we had planned to have dinner before a doctors appointment and had to leave before we even got our pizza. Was a waste of money and pizza still hasn’t arrived as I type this so I can only assume it will be cold. I said to the guy this will be the last time I order as this keeps happening far to often and he said “ ok fine bye” I mean this has gone so far downhill from when I first started going. Not how you run a business at all. I’m tired of rude customer service
jon.goldman112/14/19, 8:32 p.m.
Ehhhh not the best but could be worse. No flop one bite everybody knows the rules
zaacrew12/8/19, 7:08 p.m.
Great pie. Solid ingredients and one of the best in the area. Close to the 8’s.
noah.kirchoff4/7/19, 11:18 p.m.
Good slice decent on flop little greasy overall good cheap pizza
mangler0071/19/19, 6:57 p.m.
Had the Calamari 8.2 Chicken fettuccine 7.6 Caesar salad 8 Slice 7.4