Johnny's Pizzeria

There should be an 8.9, but waiting 75 minutes for a pizza is not acceptable when you’re dining in.

Was pretty good pizza, the ratios were just messed up. Not enough cheese was a tad too thin for my liking and once the pizza cooled down it seemed there wasn’t enough sauce. Good cook time and very crispy

Tony pepperoni doing gods work bringing me pizza from Mt Vernon. Slice was good enough for me to not leave any left over for franky fingas.

Slice is as thin as a cracker just how I like it. Sauce on top cause that’s the best part of slice. Play to your strengths. Overall soliddd slice could eat it all day long

Good slice the undercarriage was the best part this reminds me of an Earnie’s style a bit but not executed as good still a very good slice fingas will be taking this down with me shortly. We gonna be eating like the Koreans are marching down rimlet and I’ll tell you that for freeeee🇮🇹🤌🏼

Really great tasting pizza just a bit too crunchy for me though.

After spending two weeks away from New York pizza WOW great to be home

Best pizza I have ever had. The crunch is something I can’t even describe.

Best pie I've had in a long while, maybe the crispiest I've ever had. Cool old school experience. Line around the corner before it opened. Took an hour to get the pizza but I wasn't going to start any trouble in that place. Cash only ... A lot of my highest scores go out to fancier pizza places but in this category I would say only Sally's in New Haven is better and that's because of the sauce.

This is a 7 at best. If I wanted a cracker I would slap some cheap pasta sauce on a Ritz. Overrated.

Johnny’s Pizzeria is a culinary masterpiece, delivering a symphony of flavors that waltz on your palate. The crust achieves the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, providing a delightful foundation for the robust tomato sauce.

Incredible bar pie

The best pizza I’ve ever had

Pizza is so up my alley. Crispy, thin, and right about of ingredients. I had rated this an 8.9 before but have been going back because it’s just the best, right after Johnny’s on Bleeker St.. It’s a must visit if you live in NY. Make the trip out!

A tiny bit too greasy but overall very good

Saturday night, 8pm. Walked right in. No wait. It’s good. Is it 9.1 good? No. I like the atmosphere, the decor, the old 70s feel of a pizza place. I like the family business aspect. It’s not corporate or run by snooty manager. No pizza by the slice is a bummer. And it’s good…but not 9.1.

Really wonderful. Crisp and thin and smooth sauce and cheese. Only shortcoming is that the char flavor really lingers. Really an amazing pie.

Closed the loop on this mt Vernon joint. Wasn’t disappointed. Big fan of the small pie option, flavor and crunch

Best pizza I’ve ever had. Paper thin, crispy, classic bar style pizza. It’s worth a trip from anywhere