John's of Bleecker Street

Dough was thin and crispy, crust was like biting into freshly baked bread. I think the biggest difference is how good the sauce is. Lived up to the hype.

For me this is a solid high 8s but I probably wouldn’t go over 9. The tomato sauce is delicious. The crust is nice and crispy but honestly could have been a little bit crispier. A bit soggy in the center of the pie. It was excellent but it didn’t change my life.

Uhhh yeah that lived up to the hype.

Great pizza. Met my expectations. Sauce slightly sweeter than I prefer but no complaints.

Dave was spot on!!! Did not disappoint AT ALL

first time in new york. happy to say this was my first slice of NY pizza.

A bit overcooked on my visit, but still wonderful.

Good but not as good as expected

I walked 2.5 miles and passed dozens and dozens of pizzerias to get to this one! Worth the walk!

Worth the trip, worth the wait in line. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce is bright and fresh but not over powering and the crust is crispy but not crackery. We’ll done.

Nothing beats this pizza 🤌🏼🤌🏼🤌🏼

Absolutely worth the pilgrimage.

One Bite Fest baby slice, this was near too small to judge them on. Definitely see why Portnoy likes them, tangy acidic sauce but not some much to the point that it’s tart, thin, crispy, crunchy the whole way through. Not chewy, barely much of a cornicione. It’s got fresh mozzarella and sauce on top. Of course, it’s well done bordering on crunchy crust. I think it was very good. It’s must-try. If I had no idea who this was though, it wouldn’t be a 9. This is some of the best non-artisan crust you’re gonna get. Expect a well executed, straight old school coal fired New York pie.

Absolutely phenomenal. Great crunch/char that can’t be replicated. Divine sauce to cheese ratio. Worth waiting outside in the rain

Can’t do much better than this place. Insanely good pizza.

I can’t imagine pizza getting better than this and I just came from Italy. Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had

My favorite pizza in NYC. Try the Jimmy Gambino and the Meat Lovers

Very very good pizza!

Pizza was excellent! Great cook, great flavor, thin, crispy and coal fired deliciousness!

One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Maybe the best. Brooklyn/New York style. Everything is so damn good

Good.. not the best I’ve ever had. Great crust and undercarriage, fresh tomato sauce. It lacks that spice zest I get in Chicago pizza. Sausage is average. Needs more oregano, garlic/seasoning. Solid nonetheless. Worth going back but not the best ever.