John's of Bleecker Street

Worth the wait, the sauce and dough is amazing.

By far the best cheese pie I’ve ever had. No other words needed.

Hands down all time favorite pizza joint. Great tang to the sauce & basil makes any pie special.

10/10 dough Amazing cheese, fresh but slightly bland sauce.

Taste was (somewhat) there but crisp was nowhere to be found. Overall, disappointing considering the hype. Thankfully didn’t wait too long (~20 min on a Wednesday night) or else this score would’ve been lower.

Solid pie, gotta stick with the classics and go cheese. Sauce has a good tang to it and the crust had a nice char. Limited seating might have to wait but they move quick and cost is super affordable for NY

Slightly below Dave’s score; fantastic taste but a little soupy and cheesy.

Wow.

All the best characteristics + the char. Excellent.

Haven’t been to New York in 7 years, and this is the first pizza I have had to memory that was this good. Amazing. Next trip to New York will be a pizza trip and will try all the other places, but this place did not disappoint!

Davey Pageviews wasn’t lying

Loved the crust, sweet sauce was wonderful, and definitely worth the 30 minute wait

Best pizza we found in NYC hands down!!! Flavor of the sauce can not be duplicated…go get yah some!

Crust was a bit hard. Still excellent

This is easily the best pizza I’ve had in my entire life

Unreal pie, my video got deleted because it was far too good for any you to handle. Nine Point Five.