John's of Bleecker Street

Tasty sauce, great cheese and the crust had a nice stretch. Had a bit too much flop. Could have been a high 8 with a little more time in the oven.

I had high hopes with all the hype but I have to be truthful. They must of has a off day when I went. Looking at Dave's review that was 💯 not the pizza we got. I have opened pizza restaurant's I understand dough. My pizza had flop and was not crunchy. With all the high reviews on here I know something was off. I look forward to going back.

Place is great. Plain cheese with pepper can’t miss

It was pretty good. The cheese quality was great. The sauce had a twang, and the crust was good. I wish the bottom had a little crisp to it.

My top pizza. We had this when we were visiting Manhattan to see Billy Joel and this was a must stop. They let us check out the coal fired oven which you could feel the heat from across the restaurant

Excellent! Best of the trip so far.

Crust is perfect. Cheese is good. Sauce is a bit sour. We also got a cherry pepper meatball pie and that was better but the crust couldn't hold the weight of the toppings.

Wished for a LITTLE more cheese. Phenomenal though.

No slices… just pies. Smoky flavor, amazing crust, amazing sauce, my favorite in NY

fire

Is it the best slice of pizza you’ll ever have? Probably.

Good pizza, waited like 30 minutes to get it but it was worth

Very good. Some of the best pizza I’ve had for sure.

Almost perfect pizza! Very crispy, sauce had a good tang to it. Cheese was melted perfectly. Def a go to spot when in NY. Feels like it wouldn’t travel that well but the eat in was perfect.

Best pizza I’ve ever had. Sauce is amazing, crust is crisp and crunchy. Excellent flavoring. Only downside is a tiny bit of flop.

Lives up to the hype

Hands down BEST pizza I have ever had - I could’ve kept ordering and eating the original pie. It was DELICIOUS!! The cheese, the sauce, the crust - truly incredible!