John's of Bleecker Street

This is good pizza. If you like thin crust, zero-flop pies, this is for you. Everything is technically sound and the spot is of course legendary. However, in no world is this a 9 or above. That’s not a dig, an 8.2 is a massive score, I just think the establishments reputation boosts most consumers perception. I waited years to try this and, honestly, I doubt I’d go out of my way in the future.

Great pie, better history

Best pizza I’ve ever had

Good pizza don’t get me wrong, but 9.3 is grossly high for its bland profile. One would expect better sauce for a pizza of such “prestige”. Honestly could find better canned sauce at a farmers market. Not to mention half my pizza was just sauce, and was absent of cheese. It’s good and all, but it’s been absurdly gassed up. - this marks the end for anyone wanting a review- buffalopizzaguy you’re still a bitch. The fellas and I own you. We may not have been on our game as of recent but you’re still our submissive little twink fuck toy. Bald pussy..

The crisp on the bottom is great you can definitely taste that it's coal fired. The sauce and cheese do compliment each other well. For my palette, it's an 8.9, which is great. I've found other NY pies that I like better.

Great puzza Dave had it right. Great undercarriage cracker thin with good crunch. Sauce has a great zing not to mention the fast service definitely worth trying.

Most unbelievable pizza I’ve ever had. I’d kill my first born for just one more slice.

Unbelievable! Great undercarriage, hardly any flop, and great crust!

Nice.

Got inside after a quick 5-10 min. Slice was immaculate.

Not enough cheese/sauce for me

Doesn’t get better than this. Vibes were spot on and the service was speedy. 10/10

I went half cheese and half sausage. Both were worth it. The crust and sauce were simply amazing.

I’m from Youngstown Ohio (which allegedly has good pizza) and this is the best pie I’ve ever had.

A little light on flavor. Nice texture but slightly under-crisped.

Lived up to the hype. Good NY style pie.

Could’ve got lighter on the sauce. Best pie of my life.

Beautiful classic pie but it’s missing something, no flop but also no give, hard like a board. Undeniable sauce but not on the same level as other competitors. Inconsistent.