John's of Bleecker Street

Disappointed to be honest. Was expecting this to knock my socks off. Their pepperoni seems cheep low quality. Wasn’t a bad pizza just has a lot of hype.

Great tasting sauce, good crust, too much flop. Worth the hype.

Prez is right…the best in NYC hands down.

Pretty much perfect. Cheese-Sauce-Crust ratio was on point. Slightly more chew to the crust than Sally’s. Not sure if this can be beat.

The taste of the cheese and dough makes this stand above any. Crispy and yummy. Could eat a whole pie.

It’s good. Not mind blowing. It needed to be cooked longer, it had some flop, and it needed some more sodium/salt. The sauce was good but it was a tiny bit bland with the cheese. You can tell quality fresh ingredients are used so on a bad day it’s still great. Not the best in New York though. I’ll try again in the future.

textbook. wonderful.

My pie was pretty burnt on the bottom of one side and of course the first slice I grabbed was the most charred. Sauce was good, cheesy was eh, and it was too chewey for my liking. Idk I kind of want to try it again one day based on the hype.

Really great flavored pizza, almost perfect. They should’ve let the crust cook another minute or 2 and I would’ve rated 9.4 or 9.5. I’m a Jersey boy who’s picky about my pizza! 👌🏼

Honestly near perfect pizza. Best I’ve ever had. Great char and undercarriage. Perfect ratio of sauce to cheese.

Basically a perfect pizza. I was shocked how sweet the sauce is, and very good. Perfect char and near burnt bubbles. Light and crisp. 9.5

On the NY scale, I give it an 8.8. Definitely a good, well above average NY Pie.

Thought it was gonna be better

Hmmmmmm

This really is the best pizza in new york

One of my favorites I’ve ever had!

Solid pizza. Bit of flop but still great flavor

Hard to score over Angelos, so it’s a tie