John's of Bleecker Street

Very thin, buttery crust. Thick concentrated sauce. Amazing.

Excellent. Perfect char. Worth its legendary status.i understand why it is a Portnoy favorite. Good tomato to cheese ratio and a chewier crust than the New Haven coal oven pies….. must be the water. I’ll be back.

Cars 2

Worth the trip for one of the best in NYC.

Not my type of pizza, sauce is to sweet

Loved it.

An absolutely must have!!! WOW!!!

Good pizza but nothing to write home about.

Coal oven, sauce reminded me of review view, great great pizza

Been following Portnoy since COVID. I'm from the UK. I came all the way over just to try this pizza. Did not disappoint.

It lives up to the hype. Incredible sauce, crisp, crust.

No way it’s a 9 Frankie!

What a pie. The sauce leads the show. Nice tang hits you after a few chews. The cheese is tasty. Didn’t disappoint

Here it is. The review of reviews. Daves most referenced pizza and it’s a 7.8… Pretty disappointed. I’m 23 now and have wanted to try this pizza since I was like 17. It’s clear to me now that all Dave likes is a thin pizza made with extremely fresh ingredients cooked perfectly. Nothing wrong with that, but I prefer some more taste. Now that I basically live in NYC, I’m going to try a few more big ones from Dave’s list. 7.8.

What more can you say than a perfect cheese pie. Perfect under carriage with a sauce and cheese combo that are made to perfection. To top it off the ambience and decor add to that old-school fresh pizzeria deal.

Amazing taste, less crunch than expected, but still has it. Best pepperoni slice, and arguably cheese as well.

Was hoping for the 9.3 but sadly is just a standard pie.

Outstanding. Thin & crispy. Delicious cheese and pepperoni