John's of Bleecker Street

Fabulous pizza. Perfect crust. A- on flop. A touch too saucy.

Does not live up to the hype. Solid pizza, but this pie does not even measure up to the two other places right down the block, l’industrie and mamas too. Johns is similar to Joes pizza with less flop. Sauce is sweet, cheese has no taste, undercarriage is slightly above average. Johns deserves a solid score of 7.8, but I would not travel far for it.

The crunch. The thinness. The sauce. Mamma Mia. The best pizza I’ve ever had.

Phenomenal pizza cooked to perfection

This pizza did not disappoint. It was excellent!

Great flavor but the middle of the pie was soggy. Service was outstanding and the atmosphere is awesome.

Great tasting pie. Would’ve liked a more consistent covering of sauce for it to elevate into the 9s. Visiting from the UK

The Jimmy Gambino pie is off the hook !!! And the regular pie is delicious , been coming to John’s since the early 90’s , they are the best pizza in manhattan !!!

Fantastic Pizza, great customer service!

The sauce tang 🤤perfectly crispy crust while nice and doughy in the middle 👌🏽

Excellent! Fried platter appetizer was good too.

Elite crunch, looked too cheesy but it was perfect, somehow held up. Tomato sauce was amazing and pepperonis had spice. Best I’ve had

Great pizza! Crispy crust and flavorful sauce!

Great pizza! Amazing sauce and dough! Great atmosphere and fast service too!

Holy shit…this was amazing! You can taste every ingredient in this pie!

Pizza was great, the environment felt like if you had to describe to someone what a pizza restaurant would look like in a movie