John's of Times Square

Fantastic Pizza. The building also has stained glass all over which indicates to me that this is where Jesus eats pizza.

Best cheese and buffalo chicken pizza I've ever had.

Good New York pie here. Nice cheese to sauce ratio, great crunch. Floppy but crunchy. Well done. Till next time NYC

Really delicious sauce and cheese. A bit too greasy, crust was unremarkable. All in all, really enjoyed it.

this is a tricky one… the potential was totally there but unfortunately we picked it up & walked for a while so when we eventually tried the pie, it wasn’t warm🥲 but the undercarriage & sauce was impressive👌🏼this is a pie worth trying!

Not sure if we hit it on a bad night or not. Under cooked in my opinion. Crust could have been crispier and too much cheese and not enough sauce.

Greasy and floppy but tastes amazing

Very solid

Very solid New York style pizza. Amazing cheese good crust and overall great pizza. Tastes very good. A little greasy only negative.

Great cheese. Pepperoni lacks a bit. Crust is gas

Excellent pie, loved the base and the sauce.

So good I forgot to take a picture

Great pizza. Not heavy on the sauce but maybe a bit greasy. Eat it hot for prime taste

Really great New York Staple, Bleaker is a little better but still awesome pie for a good price! No slices though

Solid pizza. Good crust, flavorful sauce, and nice cheese without that greasy after taste

Good Pizza. Under carriage was doughy but the crust was solid. Cheese and sauce where both good a little soupy. John’s of Times Square is good but cannot compare to John’s Of Bleecker

Great taste and quality, would have been a 9 if not for it having a bit too much oil which made it a little soggy. Overall very good

Great crust, not too heavy, not much flop. Great taste.

Great pizza at this place. Very cheesy and flavorful sauce. No flop at all except for the greasier slices. Crispy crust. Everything you could want in a pizza.