John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Consistency fantastic

Crust not crunchy. Smh

If there is exposed sauce on the pie I prefer that it's on the edge of the crust and not where there should be cheese.

Arcade pizza

Alright Frankie…an old fashioned and a sausage and tomato pie in 50 degree weather. Perfect bar pie. Little flop. Highly recommend. That’s a review!

John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Little flop very good. Not an 8.4 for us but very good.

Atmosphere, service and most especially the pizza was phenomenal, must try, sit down and relax with your friends and family

Solid pie. No flop, excellent sauce and cheese. The crust was good but not the best I’ve had. Overall, this is a pizza I would definitely get again.

Stopped here because of the Dave review. Very glad we did. Great pizza. Very happy. Nice thin crisp. Delicious

Undercooked but phenominal sauce and delicious cheese more than make up for it. Very good NYC pizza.

Great tasting pizza. Pretty good integrity

Excellent taste. Floppy and pretty wet in the middle.

Great atmosphere in olf church. Pizza was very good. Thin light and tasty. Just under an 8 for me.

Crust is perfect, sauce is decent, no flop

As advertised - here with fam 4 years ago and now a lone soldier - so good !