La Margherita Pizzeria & Restaurant

This is as standard as standard gets. Football pie, and everything is just as you would expect. Little heavy on the cheese… little greasy… this place is in line with a lot of pizzerias on the island. I’ve been here a few times a looooong time ago. I was very surprised how quiet it was at 1:30 on a Monday. I remember the place being packed… it’s a big place, plenty of seating.. and very standard. Oh, and a decent amount of specialty slices which is what I would get if I ever came back.

Good pizza, lots of cheese

W pizza

Great place to grab slices with the family during a baseball tournament. Got a slice of white, grandma, and bbq chicken, along with a margarita cooked in their 90 year old wood fired oven. A little heavy on the cheese for me but my family loved it! Undercarriage on the slices was nice and crispy.

Good but I prefer if it had a little less cheese

Classic old school pizza place and above average slice.

Way to much cheese, solid crust game. Sauce is a bit bland

Slop & Flop, they also rammed bbq slice, Buffalo slice and two reg slices in one small box. Good taste is the saving grace from a zero.

Tried to order a cheese pizza in brick oven. Apparently a cheese pizza is 16” not in brick oven. A 12” pizza in the brick oven is Margaretta style only. Folks were very nice even if we disagree about the rules of pizza. Good pie, crust is undercooked, sauce is a little sweet but good. Can’t comment on cheese, it was a Margarita. Good pie.

Good slice decent crisp, special slices looked good

Tried the deep dish and regular plain slices. Regular: Excellent crust - crisp and thin, as a proper Long Island slice should be. Little on the greasy side and could have used a more sauce. Overall this pizza is very crushable. I’d give this slice a 7.4! Deep dish: Normally not the type to like a lot of cheese.. but damn is this mozz high quality! The crust is the real star of the show however - light, chewy and very flavorful. As far as deep dishes go I’d rate this a solid 8.0.

Really cool spot. Crispy, nice thick sauce and cheese is great. Sicilian was also terrific.

Zero flop. Too heavy on the cheese

Social distancing pizza review- slice was average, could use more sauce. Crust was nice and crunchy and there was a lot of cheese. Just missing a bit of flavor

Is like long island has trouble getting all the point s down... the crust and cheese is perfect but the sauce flavor doesn't jump out at it you... it isn't terrible it's not great either but enjoyable slice

Crust and cheese 9/10 Sauce is 3/10

A true Long Island slice, almost perfectly executed. Crisp crust straight through, flavorful sauce and sharp mozzarella. Worth a hike, give it a try!

Crispy crust good sauce and cheese great slice

Really cheesy, good sauce, pretty greasy, crust is good , decent slice Brick oven

Good crust, bland flavor and not enough sauce. I could only taste the cheese which was hard like the slice had been sitting out all day. (Bonus review on Dr. Pepper: no bottles or cans, and the fountain pepper was not good. Definitely not all 23 flavors) (The random picture is because I waited until after finishing the slice to find out the app would not upload my original picture)