About La Margherita Pizzeria & Restaurant
91 Yelp Reviews
t-rex.pizza9/5/20, 8:26 p.m.
I’ll start by saying this a true brick oven style margarita pie. Perfectly cooked, sauce is fire, and great undercarriage. Really top quality for LI and worth the drive. I also tried the football slice that was a 7.9 and had all the same flavor profiles. If you’re within 15 minutes, order it up it stays great in the box. Or if you’re driving by on the LiE, get off and go enjoy! Best in Suffolk!
thomas.longspaugh8/13/20, 6:35 p.m.
Tried the deep dish and regular plain slices. Regular: Excellent crust - crisp and thin, as a proper Long Island slice should be. Little on the greasy side and could have used a more sauce. Overall this pizza is very crushable. I’d give this slice a 7.4! Deep dish: Normally not the type to like a lot of cheese.. but damn is this mozz high quality! The crust is the real star of the show however - light, chewy and very flavorful. As far as deep dishes go I’d rate this a solid 8.0.
anthonyg8/8/20, 4:34 p.m.
Really cool spot. Crispy, nice thick sauce and cheese is great. Sicilian was also terrific.
andrew.lembo5/3/20, 7:27 p.m.
Social distancing pizza review- slice was average, could use more sauce. Crust was nice and crunchy and there was a lot of cheese. Just missing a bit of flavor
juan.rivera24/29/20, 7:22 p.m.
Is like long island has trouble getting all the point s down... the crust and cheese is perfect but the sauce flavor doesn't jump out at it you... it isn't terrible it's not great either but enjoyable slice
collwilx8211/13/19, 6:35 p.m.
A true Long Island slice, almost perfectly executed. Crisp crust straight through, flavorful sauce and sharp mozzarella. Worth a hike, give it a try!
eddie.o'brien110/1/19, 10:47 p.m.
Really cheesy, good sauce, pretty greasy, crust is good , decent slice Brick oven
john.grigonis9/1/19, 2:09 a.m.
Great crust, perfect amount of chewiness and good crunch on the bottom (I'd prefer it a little crunchier personally) Sauce leaves much to be desired. Very bland with little flavor. Cheese is nice and not to greasy. Overall, not the worst but far from the best
larry.h8/21/19, 8:38 p.m.
Good crust, bland flavor and not enough sauce. I could only taste the cheese which was hard like the slice had been sitting out all day. (Bonus review on Dr. Pepper: no bottles or cans, and the fountain pepper was not good. Definitely not all 23 flavors) (The random picture is because I waited until after finishing the slice to find out the app would not upload my original picture)
dylan.wolf18/20/19, 7:55 p.m.
Decent gma slice not the best in the area however. And the cut was awkwardly long but would eat the slice again. Side note not regarding the review the buffalo slice is definitely the worst I’ve ever had Grandma Slice
pizzareviewsfromthe8457/26/19, 11:14 p.m.
Needs to be less messy and more crusty. Dangling tip Great taste
shadymilkman7/12/19, 5:01 p.m.
Classic Friday night slice! VERY VERY CHEESEY. Caught this slice right out the oven. The slice is pretty heavy from all the cheese and this throws off the ratio and really hides the sauce which is a shame as when you get to the crust where the cheese isn't so heavy it seems to have pretty good flavors. Good crunch on the crust but alittle underwhelming. Overall this is a good local slice that would totally do as your local pizza joint.
willo6/26/19, 6:42 p.m.
Deep dish BBQ chicken slice. No flop surprisingly, but very cheesy. Good crust. Def better than average.
rob.callie4/18/19, 3:36 a.m.
Deep dish was decent alil plain but good crust Grandma was excellent thin crust crispy sauce was fresh and delicious nice lil spot wasn’t expecting it to be so good will def come back there brick oven is absolutely beautiful
carlos.marques4/15/19, 12:16 a.m.
Excellent presentation, it tasted a little undercooked but overall a good slice of pizza