La Nonna's Pizzeria

Don’t let the picture fool you. Nice Good Friday slice

Floppy, Little crisp. Good football pizza

Surprisingly very good. No under carry. One bite everyone knows the rules

Buffalo chicken slice, with excellent crust

Going to grade this picture and not just the slice. All 3 were excellent and the sauce was very tasty. Will be back

Ill admit there's some flop to it, but don't let that deter you from trying this place. The crust has a perfect amount of crunch but the undercarriage is still soft but flavorful. Best plain slice I've had so far in Huntington.

Usually has a good slice, but today he just didn’t have it. No crisp. Atrocious flop. Sauce had nice flavor, but you have to show up to play everyday.

Flop city on this one. Sauce is good but that’s about all I liked here.

Regular: super crispy, sauce and cheese are delicious and a good ratio. This an easy 8.7 Sicilan: a really good cook on the dough, this is a real good slice. 8.9 Margarita: this would have been one of the best margarita slices I've ever had if it wasn't for the strong use of garlic. Everything on this slice is perfect except for that. Still a good slice. I wasn't expecting much from a small place like this but they are killing it here.

I’m a Nassau guy , so when I goto suffolk this place is my goto , crust is perfect , no flop , cheese is perfectly placed and it’s homemade sauce is better then grandma’s Not greasy at all this place shouldn’t be missed always enjoy this place hidden gem !

Very underrated slice, the reason the picture is what it is... couldn’t stop eating. Crust fire. Devoured that’s a review. Peace

Regular - 6.8 Sicilian A 7.4

La Nonna’s makes a really tasty regular slice. Really good sauce and cheese blend. Crust is good even if the slice was a little floppy. Customer service is the best the staff in there are always extremely friendly. Not relevant to the review of the regular slice itself, but if you enjoy speciality slices they make an excellent Ziti slice

Good football pizza, tiny flop, nice crust, sauce actually has flavor, good cheese. Very solid

Football pizza, serious flop, great sauce, easy to eat

No flop. Little greasy. Crust is crunchy with a little softness. Sauce is good, and lots of cheese. Strong slice.

Good sauce. No flop. Overall good slice.

Looks better than it tastes. Thin with a crispy bite and crust but doesn’t have much flavor at all. Very bland.

nice thin crust and average sauce

Solid football slice. Zero NY flop, and good crunch in the bite.