Lazzara's Pizza & Subs

A solid New York-style slice with a sauce that really stands out. The crust is definitely on the thinner side and has a decent amount of flop for a slice this size. I personally would have preferred a little more thickness, but the flavor makes up for it. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is well balanced, and the sauce is what separates this slice from the rest. As of now, this is my top pizza choice in Emerald Isle.

Very good pizza! Huge slice for $4!!! Nice crisp on the undercarriage, but needed some more crisp on the actual crust

Floppy undercarriage but delicious taste. Pricey for overall score but it’s very solid pizza.

Solid NY Style Pizza. In my opinion , the best NY style pizza in western Carteret/Swansboro area. Nice undercarriage.

Solid pizza that fed our crew of 11. Everyone went back for seconds. Favorite part was the cheese. It gets busy because it’s debatably the best pizza on the island. Would recommend

The best pizza on the island and probably the best in NC. Never disappoints.

fantastic pizza and steak subs

The best pizza in Carteret County hands down. If you don't mind a light grease or flop, you'll love this pizza. It has a fair amount of sauce with a really good classic taste. It's crispy if you eat it hot. The price beats its competitors.

Way to greasy, but overall taste is good

Decent slice. Some flop. Nice dough. Crispy crust. Huge slice.

This was a good pie. Great service. Had a little chat around the crust and a lot of flop. We ordered a medium and should have ordered a small, it was a big pie. There was a lot of grease which lowered the score. Good flavor for the total score. If there wasn’t so much flop and grease, easy 7.9 I would eat again.

Crunchy, chewy crust. Herbaceous sauce. Best pies on the island

I’m not Dave Portnoy so my likes are different. There’s flop, which is okay with me. The sauce is good but could be a little sweeter. I like the dough, it’s crispy and a little burnt. Again, that’s okay because I like that. Cheese is quality and no grease whatsoever. There’s a lot to like here. We ordered delivery and it was perfect when it came to the door. I rated Michelangelo’s higher but that was based off my first experience. My second experience wasn’t nearly as good but hey, one bite... I really liked this and will come back.

Good flavor and in defense of Lazzara’s they were swamped. I just wanted some crunch and got more soggy/chewy. I’ll try again when it’s not an hour wait.

Pizza was good, crispy crust, good sauce. Was a little greasy, but overall a good average pizza.

Solid pizza. Too much grease