Lazzara's Pizza

Actually really light and solid, crust deceptively thin and crispy. Not quite a red top or upside down but close, honestly maybe better. Would eat again

I was so excited to try a 9+ pizza in NYC, but this is a massive let down and it shouldn’t be on the 9ins. Too sweet for a pizza. Sorry Dave but you weren’t honest here and for that reason I’ll give a 6,2. People need to read the reviews before they try. 21$ for a pizza that is not even tasty. Further down the street on the 6 Av & West 29 St, is a 1$ slice which is definitely the best in the area.

One bite everyone knows the rules. Crispy as fuck. Nice undercarriage. Amazing sauce nice light dough and crispy end crust. Everything about this pizza is awesome. Service is good here workers lacked charm but who cares with pie like this!!

Shocked that this was a 9+. It's good but definitely not "make a trip to try it" good. Given the 9 score I'm actually a little disappointed. I think people in New York just think their pizza is god 😂 Shame on Dave for giving us a 9+

Very good sauce, not too sweet, and the right amount of tangy. The cheese falls apart, the dough is a buttery but is very sturdy

So I can’t complain as it was very good but I can’t give it a 9+. Great atmosphere, pizza was good.

Don’t be deterred by the exterior. It seems like your walking into a 2nd floor walk up apartment. But low and behold is what seems like a speakeasy for pizza and great Italian. It’s definitely Portnoy style and possibly the thinnest crust possible. Which can hold the weight of any topping with no flop. The sauce and cheese are well distributed over the crust. Even being so thin doesn’t just slide off. Or overpower the crust. Awesome experience.

If you're from Philly, this is the square version of Tacconellis. Perfectly crispy every bite. Sweeter sauce. Same ratio of sauce to cheese. Damn close to perfect pizza

Near perfection.

Sorry, this is not a 9.3 it never could be and makes me wonder if this app is on the level with DP’s score. The cheese is tough, the crust is way too thin, the sauce is very sweet. Meh.

Really don’t see the appeal here. Crust was great but the rest kinda sucked

Came in with high expectations and slightly disappointed. However, very solid. The sauce was the best part, it had great tang. The sliced cheese felt kinda basic. The pizza looks nice and crisp but the bottom wasn’t as charred/crispy as I was hoping for. 9.3 by Dave seems pretty high.

Lazzara’s was the only place I hadn’t tried on the island that Dave had scored above a 9.0. Although his other high scoring pizzas were good or great, this was not. Lazzara’s cheese pizza was average. There are much better pies in the area.

Doughy, crispy, and delicious.