2,019 Yelp Reviews
sanandres1/20/24, 4:11 p.m.
Soggy and greasy Service was pretentious Don’t really need our business All hype There are dozens of better places in the area including Luigi’s Also expensive Don’t recommend
daniel.mccombie12/17/23, 12:39 a.m.
Light like an angle made it. Crust is crunchy/crispy at the top and more chewy/crisp in the center which is perfect. Sauce and crust objectively perfect. Cheese subjectively amazing. Contender for best pie I’ve ever had.
16 views•1 like
daniel.wilton12/1/23, 2:14 a.m.
Lives up to the hype for sure. Simple and good. Quality ingredients & amazing ambiance inside. Thin crust with a good chew that holds up to all the cheese & sauce. Was fairly easy to get a table on a Thursday night @ 5pm by getting in line around 3:45pm so don’t be intimidated by what you hear.
silvertongue11/22/23, 4:49 p.m.
Went on a 5000 mile journey to eat at Lucali, it didn't disappoint, would make the trip any day. Absolutely incredible, emotional experience. The best pizza I have ever eaten, and it was the last on our New York adventure. The blend of cheeses and the crisp crust was to die for, the aroma and flavour of the wood oven really came through. An overall tremendous experience. There is nothing I could say or do to make this pizza better.
peter.galindo10/26/23, 11:23 p.m.
The photo might not do it justice. Incredible pie. Light, looks cheesy but doesn’t have a lot of cheese… well worth the hour and a half wait.
matt.earhart110/23/23, 7:00 p.m.
The hype is real. Lucali is a very special place. Simple, no flop crust, perfect char, fresh ingredients. Just good pizza. The wait to get in will piss you off.
justin.bodfield10/14/23, 2:06 p.m.
Look it’s a Chef JB review. The pizza was fucking fantastic to say the least. JB loves his SAUCE, so this one came with the heat. Lucali you snapped with the sauce. This sauce is the experience in its self, flavor OVERLOAD. Truly amazing from the fresh garlic, fresh basil, and amazing tomatoes. The cheese was hand pulled mozzarella and was the best cheese pull ever. The crust had the best crunch of my life. Buttttttt the line to get the reservation was ridiculous. Hour and half wait to get a seat at 10 pm like bruh come on Lucali. I get there is limited seats and I got to see David Beckham but come on. The pizza was fantastic, the waitress was absolutely in the right for her spot btw. Shoutout the wait line from 10/13. But the experience is a once in a lifetime mobster classic Italiano spot that is magnificent. Love you Lucali, but please make a line for a slice to-go. DP you did us well brotha. But fuck that line, also waitress next time I promise to have your back! CHEF JB-we outta here!
36 views•5 likes
columbuspizzaking10/7/23, 2:18 p.m.
This is the best pizza I have ever had. I know everyone has there own but this is by far the best I have eaten. From the crust to the sauce , the toppings it was everything I expected . If you are a pizza lover this is by far a must stop I seriously would catch a flight in the am to eat in the evening and fly home right after. ( and we are seriously thinking about it) It is that good. And the Stromboli is just as good!!!!!!
ben.schwartz210/2/23, 1:44 p.m.
One bite everyone knows the rules. Great pie wow. Nothing more to say