Cheese pie: not as great as most say it is; top-notch ingredients in terms of quality (cheese, dough, sauce, fresh basil); basil does not go well with the pizza, adds a nice flavor, but I would take it off before biting into the actual pizza; too floppy for my liking, cheese falls off very easily, leaves you with about a bite with cheese per slice; dough is SPECTACULAR, don't think I've had better; decently crisp, but definitely not crisp enough; overall, slightly underwhelming because it seems the pizza doesn't add up the sum of its parts, albeit VERY GOOD parts, perhaps because it is a bit sloppy; also, could definitely use some quality control on the garlic, both my friend and I ended up biting into an entire clove of garlic each (8.7/10)
frank.facciponti8/9/20, 5:14 p.m.
This pizza was delicious! It had more flop and less crunch then I expected. However, the taste and flavor were amazing. We will definitely go there again.
lewis.gilbert7/18/20, 3:22 p.m.
Takeout but still amazing. 10 minute wait right now is amazing
neil.sweeney16/28/20, 5:30 p.m.
Ordered 1 pep and 1 plain for takeout. Fortunately there’s a nice shaded park with tables 2 blocks away since there’s no dine in. Pizza was as expected. Plain was light and crispy and delicious and Pepperoni always kicks it up a notch. Reheated slices the next day was just as good. Great night!
emjaysea6/27/20, 12:26 a.m.
Super thin and crispy crust. Sauce is not overly acidic or sweet and the cheese has a nice elasticity and a mild flavor. Bonus points on the fresh basil. Now, is this worth a 2+ hour wait? No. You know what might be though? Their calzones. They’re easily a 10+, they are that good.
jerbraska6/25/20, 5:45 a.m.
Solid slice but not as good as Di Fara’s or even Sorrento’s. Ive been to all of Prez’s 9 scorers. This wasnt the best of em, lets just put it that way.
derek.otool6/13/20, 6:50 p.m.
It was good... but cheese slip and slide on the soft side. Sauce was super flavorful.
59 views•0 likes
skgpizzaman5/24/20, 7:17 p.m.
I did the new haven pizza tour 2 weeks ago. Nothing compares to this.
112 views•7 likes
pizza_joe5/21/20, 3:30 a.m.
It was good pizza but nothing crazy. Sauce taste good but nothing really that special when I bit in. Started to taste better on my third slice. This like a 2030 type trendy pizza - and I see what people like it. Doesn’t have the old school kick. But again a very solid pie. Better places around
paulie.pizza5/17/20, 6:34 p.m.
This pizza has a combination of cheeses. You can really taste the distinctive hard cheese shaved on top. The dough is very lite and thin. The sauce on this pie has a more tomato paste taste. Overall a great pie and I’m glad I was able to try it out.
sgt.pizza5/7/20, 11:45 p.m.
Dough reminds me of pita bread, its has a really good taste to it, Sauce and cheese are really good too. Worth the wait
jay.zee5/5/20, 11:55 p.m.
so glad it lived up to the hype, by far one of the best slices i’ve ever had, lucali will not disappoint! you’re the man mark!