Lucy's New York Style Pizza

Great flavor, sauce and cheese are awesome but crust is pretty soggy. Lots of flop.

I’m from NY and this isn’t authentic NY pizza, but it’s close. Definitely the best pizza in the area

Could use more cheese, the broadway location uses more. But otherwise a solid slice. The sauce is pretty phenomenal. Very good undercard holds the whole thing together and has a unique taste of its own. So far Lucy’s at both locations is the cream of the crop in IF.

If you get out fresh, no flop, nice crunch and just right on the sauce. Although the Buffalo chicken is my favorite

Good tang in the sauce, and nice overall flavor. Crust had a great chew but needed a minute more to get the best crunch. Overall very good

I’ve had Lucy’s a dozen times. This time around we got their meaty and another specialty but overall this pizza is a solid 7.5. Great sauce and cheese and crust. Gets a lil floppy and greasy but best pizza in Idaho Falls