I’d give the square 8.9 (tastiest sweet sauce, perfect oily crunchy dough) and the regular 8.3 (crispy and wonderful just almost cracker-like and dense) for an average of 8.6 plus a bonus point for epic old school vibes and neighborhood charm and no hipsters ruining it. Went with my 2 year old son and he crushed it too. Would take visitors here. I tend to favor the modern approach lately like Manos, L’Industrie, and Wizard Hat, but for an old school NY pie I imagine this is hard to beat.
