Luigi's Pizza

Great pizza. Great sauce, nice crust.

Fantastic

Very good, traditional NY slice. Thin and crispy, solid flavor. Go with the plain slice over pepperoni, was super greasy

Very good. Everything works together good sauce decent crust and creamy mozz…good solid pizza

Incredible sauce and crust. Great blend of flavors.

Dave’s not joking and I must agree on the absolute well deserved score. I can’t even put into words how good their pizza is. If you live in New York and have not tried Luigis, you’re truly missing out.

One point lower than Portnoy’s score. Good pizza. Reasonably priced ($7 for all three slices). Friendly staff. Commendable sauce to cheese ratio. Solid undercarriage. Crust was underwhelming for me; didn’t have a distinct flavor and the plain slice on the left was a little over cooked making it slightly dry. But the one on the right was cooked better. So I guess it cancels each other out.

Great slice. Reminds me of the best Brooklyn Pizza of my youth. Squishy yet crunchy crust with great flavor. Sauce has a great kick, not too greasy.

Perfect crisp, fluffy and airy, zingy marinara, gooey cheese, crust is crunchy but maintains a balanced profile. Franklyn, this is the holy grail. Absolutely phenomenal pizza. That’s a fucking review!!!

The park is beautiful, serene. Slice is outstanding, not a 9.3 for me but definitely one of the best slices I have ever has. I prefer a different style, but once again that is on me. This is the type of pizza you tell your grand kids about. Everything about it is absolute mint

Lived in the neighborhood my whole life didn’t know about this spot. New go to spot. Not a 9 tho

Well done! Thin delicious slight crisp, not over oily, great balance with cheese to the sauce and dough, love it! It’s a 9.3 for me.

The sicilian and fresh moz slice are my favorites. The ratio of pesto on the fresh moz slice is just right. Sauce has a great tomato taste. You can tell all the ingredients are fresh. The crust on the regular slices doesn’t quite have the char that would put a pizza into the 9’s for me, but still very good. 8.2 for the pizza but 9.8 for Gio+fam, the prices, and the history.

Sooo good

Cash register hasn’t been serviced since 1941. Great pizza.

Excellent texture. Just the way you want it. Doesn’t flop. Not too oily. Old school pizza shop. Very friendly dude. Good vibes. The fresh mozzarella slice wasn’t as good as the original. The original brought me home to jersey where I grew up but with Brooklyn quality— yet not hipster

Best in Brooklyn

Margarita pizza is not to be messed with

One of the best slices in NY. Great fresh ingredients and super crispy!!! Lifelong New Yorker and this is one of the best slices I’ve had