Luigi's Pizzeria

📍 Luigi's Pizzeria — Homecrest, Brooklyn (Ave U & E 16th–17th) Score: 6.8 🍕 Review number three. John and Autz, still hungry, still honest. Today's stop: Luigi's on Avenue U. Let's get into it. The pie: this one didn't do much for us. The cheese had a weird flavor we couldn't quite place — and it wasn't hot enough or melted enough to save it. No gooey pull, no real heat, just kind of... there. Autz felt the same: not offensive, not memorable, the definition of a shrug. Then we saw the price. $3.70 a slice. That's the part that stings. We've paid less for better all over this city. So where'd we land? Autz: 6.9. John: 6.8. We settled on 6.8 — a slice that isn't bad, just nothing special, and priced like it forgot that. VERDICT: 6.8. Mid pie, premium price. Heat it up, fix the cheese, and maybe we revisit. Until then, your $3.70 has better options nearby. — 🍕 IG: @pizzaandball 🏀 Discord (link in bio) — pickup hoops & pizza reviews "Not what we have, but what we enjoy, constitutes our abundance." — Epicurus

Really bad, waste of a cheat day

Strange flavor. Not sure if it was cheese or sauce. Though it was the cheese but seems like it could actually be the sauce. Great crust. Over a 7 on the crust. Hard to get over that taste that it gives. Strange taste like I never had before...

Eh

No flop, good football slice with decent sauce and crust.

Nice flavor on this slice. Good amount of sauce. Sauce seasoned just right.