Luigi's Pizzeria

📍 Luigi's Pizzeria — Homecrest, Brooklyn (Ave U & E 16th–17th) Score: 6.8 🍕 Review number three. John and Autz, still hungry, still honest. Today's stop: Luigi's on Avenue U. Let's get into it. The pie: this one didn't do much for us. The cheese had a weird flavor we couldn't quite place — and it wasn't hot enough or melted enough to save it. No gooey pull, no real heat, just kind of... there. Autz felt the same: not offensive, not memorable, the definition of a shrug. Then we saw the price. $3.70 a slice. That's the part that stings. We've paid less for better all over this city. So where'd we land? Autz: 6.9. John: 6.8. We settled on 6.8 — a slice that isn't bad, just nothing special, and priced like it forgot that. VERDICT: 6.8. Mid pie, premium price. Heat it up, fix the cheese, and maybe we revisit. Until then, your $3.70 has better options nearby. — 🍕 IG: @pizzaandball 🏀 Discord (link in bio) — pickup hoops & pizza reviews "Not what we have, but what we enjoy, constitutes our abundance." — Epicurus

Average Brooklyn pizza

Strange flavor. Not sure if it was cheese or sauce. Though it was the cheese but seems like it could actually be the sauce. Great crust. Over a 7 on the crust. Hard to get over that taste that it gives. Strange taste like I never had before...

Eh

No flop, good football slice with decent sauce and crust.

Nice flavor on this slice. Good amount of sauce. Sauce seasoned just right.