Luigi's Pizzeria of East Setauket

Very bowling-alley/chuckie cheese-esq pizza (not a bad thing). Reminds me of younger days at birthday parties, when times were simpler. Oh how the years go by. The problem isn’t the taste, the problem is charging a regular rate for a party-esq pizza. That being said, the specialty slices are AMAZING.

Forgot flop test. Good football slice. Gives me Chuck E Cheese vibes on the look. Overall an average slice with nothing special about it but it gets the job done

very good, a little too big, floppy but also was right of of the oven

Super soggy!! Sauce is decent but the pizza itself isnt great

Nit the traditional slice but decent. Under crust could have been cooked more thus the 6.7 topside all were spot on!

Luigis

Good football pizza - nothing fancy about it but it mixes well with a few Budweisers on a fall Sunday afternoon.

I love Luigi’s so much! They have the best grandma’s slice I have ever had. The basil is perfect. My score is for the grandma, though.

Crust is nice and the underbelly is superb but this is one bland ass pizza and the sauce taste like it's from a can really disappointing for 3.50 a slice and how great the people are they have other food that's probably better... but this ain't it

Sauce wasn't that good. Crust almost ruined the slice.

Some of the more solid pizza I've had in the area. Score is legit and an homage to me predicting Prez's score for his last review in homage to the great Ray Borque. Chin up Prez. They fought hard.

Alright

Meh

Middle of line pizza, crust brings it to the 5s. That's a review.

Much better than last time. Well done is the way to go