Made In New York Pizza

Best on the UWS. Great sauce, real sausage, solid NY pizza! Pro tip: Go to this location with the gas oven not the newer locations with electric.

Solid slice, nothing to write home about. Crispy, prepared well, kind staff and will be back when in area.

Excellent slice definitely worth stopping by all their slices look great the crisp and sauce was great

Solid but a little too greasy

Had to try the Spicy Pepperoni Square while in NY for Summerslam…this slice SLAMS, very crispy and the spicy pepperoni makes this pop!!! Well done!!!

Absolute Banger crust, just enough sauce and some great shrooms for the boy. The hospitality was impeccable as the employees offered me their favorite slices and I obliged. Congrats Made In New York Pizza you have gained my approval.

Solid

Very very good. Excellent crust. Quite a bit of grease but other than that it was delicious.

The cheese and Marinara Slices were solid. The Vodka slice was flavorless.

On 11/30/24 I had cheese slice and a Spicy pepperoni slice

Sbarro vibes but squishy and weird. They lie about their score on the wall art. Go get on the 1 and go 3 stops uptown and get Sal & Carmines or Mamas Too.

ABSOL

Was in NYC and wanted to try one of Dave’s highly rated places this was 7.9 so I thought I would give it a shot Really good pizza reheated well thin,crispy good sauce & cheese was delicious happy I stopped in

Big New York flop. Sauce is good but there is lots of sauce. In all fairness was my second slice was better than the first after it had cooled.

Excellent sauce great crisp. Overall great flavor. Buffalo Chicken good too.