Madison Avenue Pizza

Good crisp. Dave spot on.

The cheese and sauce were good. The crust was inconsistent though. Half the crust was very doughy and chewy and the other half was crispy. It’s a good neighborhood pizza joint. I will give them another shot.

Great light crust with a good crunch! Sauce and toppings have great flavor

classic but really good

Killer beer and best pizza I've had in FL

Crust had slight oven taste. Not a fan of what seemed like marinara for the sauce.

Solid

Major flop, greasy, too much sauce but great crust. Cant score in the 7s.

W pizza rizz

Good NY style you can eat every day. Nice neighborhood bar vibe.

Over seasoned. Soggy. All flop. Straight up not good. Best of the bay no shot clearly a popularity contest.

Wicked large slice. Good cheese and sauce. Pretty floppy. I’d be happy with this anytime. Disclaimer - ordered a slice and not a whole pie

Grease puddle, bunch of flop. Mediocre

Very good pizza. Dough is tasty and the crust is crispy. would’ve gave it a higher score if it wasn’t as floppy.

Delicious. High quality cheese, fresh tomatoes, and a good crust.