Magpies Gourmet Pizza 4th Ave.

I’ve had Magpies many times over the years and it’s always been a solid go to pizza. In all fairness, the pizza I am reviewing was delivered and not straight out the oven. It was Luke warm at best upon arrival. (IMO, Magpies is a pizza you have to eat hot, right out of the oven). The dough when cold tends to be slightly chewy. Cheese to Sauce ratio decent on this pie, sauce had good flavor as usual. Solid pizza and beer pie if you eat in and get it fresh. 6.6 on this delivered pie. 6.9 on a fresh pie and a beer or six…

The cheese tends to overpower everything else, and it was also greasy. The sauce tasted nice.

Very rubbery, not taste to sauce, cold.

The pizza had potential but unfortunately the order was wrong instead of Sausage and Pepperoni we got Sausage and Pepperchinis. Our fault we should have checked the box. To make matters worse the pizza was cold. We tried to be fair and judge the pizza we got instead of the pizza we ordered. The woman on the phone was very nice so customer service was good. Now to the pizza, Good crust, little flop and tasty sauce. 6.1 that’s a review.

Good flavor, thick cheese. You can hear the crust breaking when you bite it. The oregano on top gives it a different flavor. Good pizza if you're walking around and want to grab a beer.