Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Mama T’s is a Long Island pizza staple. Great structure, fantastic plain slice. It sets the standard for 8.5 and above.

Absolutely zero flop. Crisp under carriage but light fluffy crust up top. Great well done cheese and sauce is sweet but not too sweet. Mama T’s have 3 locations in the area and all 3 are vastly different

Amazing slice, simply does not get any better! The perfect 10 slice has been found at Mama Theresa’s!

Solid neighborhood pizza.

Forgot to take the pic before I ate… rookie move. Good undercarriage, a little greasy but had some good crisp. Good place but def not a spot pres needs to hit up. Locals do it justice.

The regular slice was great. The sauce was slightly sweet. The Sicilian had a weird ingredient in the sauce that I couldn’t identify; tasted like Marsala wine or something. It was weird but not bad.

Good Sicilian. Good sauce to cheese ratio.

I miss my good long island pizza

Decent slice. Thin crust was good and firm and there was the right amount of cheese. It could have used a bit more sauce, but it was still good.

Solid slice. A little dry

Very good solid pizza

Very crispy, sauce is delicious, really good slice 8.3

Has some New York flop. Good flavor. Good neighborhood pizza place.

very respectable slice

Mama T’s a staple in my childhood and still good today. Cheesy, good sauce and crust with a slight crisp. Overall a good slice.

Margarita slice

Tbh it’s more like a 7.2 but gotta stick with the first score, still recommend giving it a shot

Great regular slice