Mamma Mia’s Pizzeria

I already reviewed there regular when it was Cabrinas, this is the barstool style and im a fan.

Square here was fine, taste perhaps a little dull. Staff was nice and helpful. Worth a shot, also wondering about their regular pies and if they may be better.

Bland. That is all.

This was pretty good. Crust was crispy and it seemed to travel well.

This joint replaced Cabrina’s, which was a solid 7.0 pie for $10, tremendous bang for the buck. This pizza is very similar but a lot greasier and more expensive. Mamma Mia’s charges $14.92 as an homage to when Columbus sailed the ocean blue and also charges a $1 credit card fee, which is weak as hell. Somehow, this large plain pie cost me $15.99, which is ridiculous for an average pizza. The sauce & cheese are very basic, not bad, not great, a notch above generic. The dough is rather firm, medium thickness, fairly tasty with a doughy but crispy crust. The excess grease keeps the pie from rating in the 7s and renders the overall score just a touch below the pizzeria it replaced. This isn’t bad pizza, but it’s nothing special. There are definitely cheaper and better pizzerias in the area.