Mamma Mia’s Pizzeria

I already reviewed there regular when it was Cabrinas, this is the barstool style and im a fan.

Square here was fine, taste perhaps a little dull. Staff was nice and helpful. Worth a shot, also wondering about their regular pies and if they may be better.

I heard about this place from the Jersey Pizza Joints FB page and the pics posted looked promising. I ordered the barstool pie with half pepperoni/sausage. The pizza was pretty hefty. The dough, sauce and cheese was average tasting - nothing that really stood out unfortunately.

This was pretty good. Crust was crispy and it seemed to travel well.

This joint replaced Cabrina’s, which was a solid 7.0 pie for $10, tremendous bang for the buck. This pizza is very similar but a lot greasier and more expensive. Mamma Mia’s charges $14.92 as an homage to when Columbus sailed the ocean blue and also charges a $1 credit card fee, which is weak as hell. Somehow, this large plain pie cost me $15.99, which is ridiculous for an average pizza. The sauce & cheese are very basic, not bad, not great, a notch above generic. The dough is rather firm, medium thickness, fairly tasty with a doughy but crispy crust. The excess grease keeps the pie from rating in the 7s and renders the overall score just a touch below the pizzeria it replaced. This isn’t bad pizza, but it’s nothing special. There are definitely cheaper and better pizzerias in the area.