Took a trip up to New Castle to review my first pizza in Lawrence County. I’ve done over 100 pizza reviews, and this is probably the least appetizing a pizza has ever looked. I knew there was a 5% chance I would like this pizza, and unfortunately I was right. I didn’t think anything about this pizza was good. The square slices were so heavy and did not have any crisp. The cheese on this pizza looks like a nightmare and it tasted like one as well. I was hoping that the sauce on this pizza would save the day, but it also did not taste good. My last complaint about this pizza is the dough itself did not taste good, and it actually made my car smell like bad pizza. It must be noted that New Castle, PA is the hotdog capital of the world. Next time I visit I think I will just stick to ordering some dogs instead of suffering through another bad pizza.
