Mary Lou’s Pizza

Old forge thick cuts, dry pre baked pizza shells similar to what you can get in a grocery store. Thick globs of american/mozz blend of pull off cheese, light tangy crushed tom sauce. Not for me. There is so much better in this style.

Best pizza I have had in a while. We decided to stop here on our way to Pittston. Now, I am not from PA, and this is my first time having Old Forge pizza. This is better pizza than some of the places in Jersey by far. Great, crunchy crust, and the cheese and sauce is evened out perfectly. Would recommend and would love to come back again.

Thick crunchy sweet sauce solid pizza

A quick walk for pizza.

This is their fresh tomato pie. Bursting with flavor. Piping hot and very crispy

The best in Old Forge. A little thicker than the others, and crunchy and flavorful…both the red and the white.

Very good pizza. Cheese was great, the crust was light and buttery while still having good crisp.

Light, airy, good crisp. Good pizza.

Pretty good but a little thick for Old Forge style!

Very good old Forge pizza

Love the super soft dough sitting under the cheese and sauce.

My least favorite of the three but not bad I guess this style has to be what your into. Nothing stood out but was still made right and tasted pretty good

Definitely the best of the Old Forge bunch. What this place did better than the other is it made the sauce mean something, not just something you put on top of the pizza. The dough has a little seasoning to it too that was good. Very very solid slice definitely recommend if you find yourself in the sticks of PA

Favorite old forge pizza so far. Lives up to the hype

As a disclaimer, Old Forge Pizza is not my cup of tea. But the fact that this place uses mozzarella cheese makes it a lot more palatable. Solid slice. Nice crisp and richness to the sauce. Best pizza in old forge.